#WritingCommunity #QuestionOfTheDay: To Plot Or Not To Plot?

Posted on Updated on

There’s a huge debate in the writing community whether or not having a very detailed plot outline is invaluable or a waste of time. Does it really make a book better? There’s a new story idea I’ve been toying around with and so I’d considered plotting out my next manuscript.

With my last one, I sort of had to do a super light outline because I had multiple POVs and a dual timeline. But it was the second book in a duology, and so I already knew the characters. It’s a lot different if you’re writing out a series and you already know the characters, the storyline, and kind of know what he/she would do next. It’s a lot harder to start from scratch when you are simply going off of a brand new idea that you haven’t quite fleshed out.

Some writers are detailed plotters and prefer it this way. I’ve never really been a hard-core plotter. Even with my last manuscript, I had semi-plotted it out. It was more one-liner/scene ideas/concepts.

Simple Beats/Scenes Example For Multiple POV: Here’s an uber lame-level type of breakdown that you can try if you struggle with detailed outlines. This is an example from my last manuscript (thriller/police procedural.)

  • Chapter 1 – Intro to MC (Killer POV)
  • Chapter 2 – Killer hunting victim one (Killer POV)
  • Chapter 3 – Killer kills victim one (Killer POV)
  • Chapter 4 – Intro to Detective (Detective POV)

Should Non-Plotters Try To Force Ourselves To Plot?

I don’t really consider the above an “outline” or even a plot. I tend to write out beats. I did do a very detailed character sketch of my central characters and I think that helped. But is heavy plotting better than flying by the seat of our pants? I’m not really sure what the correct answer is, to be honest. I know of several authors that swear by software like Scrivener. There is also a writing tool called Plottr. I’ve actually downloaded both and have played around with free trials.

What is my verdict on either tool?

Plottr actually gives you story templates to follow. I know there are books out there that tell you that you must plot and that it makes for a better story. I guess it depends on each writer/aspiring author/author. We’re all so different and unique. Plottr is good for building your characters. I did like following their character-building questions. Their plot templates really helped me to think about what should come next in my story, but at the same time, my ADD brain found itself switching between templates. This became confusing to me. Because there are several types of templates, and they all tell you different things. Instead of inspiring me to quickly fill out a story outline, I found myself dizzy, discombobulated, and more unsure than ever in terms of what plot should go next. Plottr is also very glitchy and has a few bugs that the software still needs to work out.

Now, about Scrivener. For some reason, there are tons of writers that love Scrivener. I’ve opened it, and the interface turns me off. I’ve tried to meander my way through, but I found the program very dry and too left brain for me. It literally hurts my head. So, I actually didn’t give it as much of a fair shake as I did Plottr. Sorry, Scrivener fans!

My verdict on plotting, I’m not really a huge fan of hard-core plots and I’m not a fan of plotting/writing software either. I’m a Word Doc gal.

Scenes & Beats For The Pantser

If you’re the “Fuck an outline!” type, then I do think having some sort of general direction is never a bad thing. I honestly believe that the story, character, circumstance, and genre are all qualifying factors. Some stories just come super easy to us. They can come to us in a very vivid way. Other times, you’ve got a vague concept and a general idea of who the character is. Regardless, I’m a firm believer in working with what you do know.

Start With A Character Sketch: Do you know who your character is? Have you done a character sketch? I like to start with the character. I always build out the character first. Do a bio of them. Get their names, age, upbringing, profession, ethnicity, idiosyncrasies, and other such details down. Build out their personality and get their voice down. Heck, get a picture of who they are. Try Googling people you might think fits your character(s). I just did my own personal “casting call” of all of my central characters with pictures, along with a breakdown of their general bio/information. When I started doing this, I was like, holy shit – this part is flowing very easy for me. Which leads me to my next point.

Write Out Beats You Do Know: Again, start with what you know. This is especially imperative if you’re suffering from depression, anxiety, any other life stressors getting in the way (like being a new mom), or good ol’ writer’s block. Writer’s block can suck, especially when you have an idea, but you’re sort of stuck. Get unstuck by working out those beats you know for sure you need to hit. There must be scenes you do know your character needs to be involved in. Once you’ve done a good character sketch, the characters tend to lead the way and the action can follow easier.

Make Your Scene List One-Liners: When you list out any scenes/beats, try making them as uncomplicated as humanly possible. Try to do simple one-liners. When you force yourself to write down simple one-liners/less than a Tweet type of quick beat, it might actually start jogging things and getting the ideas flowing.

The Bottom Line

I’m not at all an expert at plotting. If you ask me whether I’m a plotter or a pantser, I’ll tell you that I’m somewhere in the middle. Each writer is different. We all have our own writing and editing process. I think it can be fun and perfectly okay to try different approaches. If you’re a pantser, give a light outline/beat sheet a shot. If you’re a plotter, you might try to take a stab at freestyle writing without a spreadsheet! Are you a plotter, a pantser, or somewhere in the middle? Regardless of how you write your story, there is no wrong answer. 


16 thoughts on “#WritingCommunity #QuestionOfTheDay: To Plot Or Not To Plot?

    Jack Eason said:
    October 22, 2021 at 8:22 AM

    Since I began writing back in 1995, I’ve never plotted. I far prefer that the story takes me along for the ride. That way I’m always surpised. 😉

    Liked by 1 person

      S.Z. Estavillo responded:
      October 22, 2021 at 9:19 AM

      I love being surprised like that as well. Do you have at least the MC in your head and the general concept of course? 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

        Jack Eason said:
        October 22, 2021 at 9:25 AM

        Yes and yes S.Z. I’m curious what does S and Z stand for? If its a secret Don’t tell me. You know my only christian name..

        Liked by 1 person

        S.Z. Estavillo responded:
        October 22, 2021 at 9:28 AM

        Ha ha…Sonyo Zofia. My full name is Sonyo Zofia Gray. That’s a whole new debate on what name I keep for my pen name. Estavillo was my maiden name and have been using it on all social platforms, so I was told to at least keep that because of the whole “digital footprint.” I like S.Z. Gray too. Sometimes I worry Estavillo might sound too ethnic and turn off a good portion of the audience. My first name is odd because it’s Korean and it ends with an O. So, I went with initials. lol

        Liked by 1 person

        Jack Eason said:
        October 22, 2021 at 9:32 AM

        Fair enough Sonyo Zofia. Beautiful names for a beautiful soul. XX

        Liked by 1 person

    Jack Eason said:
    October 22, 2021 at 9:51 AM

    I almost forgot SZ – I’m about to write the final chapter of my latest WIP East Wind. Its a long short story about the many facets of love – one man’s love of a beautiful gaff rigged ketch and his love for two women – Lin Mae and Katya, and his daughter Tilde. Unlike my previous books I won’t be publishing it straightaway as an ebook. Rather I’ll be publishing it here on my blog – one chapter at a time. If it generates sufficient interest, then and only then will I publish it on Amazon. I’ve never written a love story before. Yes most if not all of my chief characters have romantic encounters, but thats it. Keep an eye out for it. 😉

    Liked by 1 person

      S.Z. Estavillo responded:
      October 22, 2021 at 10:17 AM

      OMG…Thanks for letting me know Jack. I would LOVE to read it. I’ll be sure to look on your blog. Is it on the East Wind tab? Is there a link?


        Jack Eason said:
        October 22, 2021 at 9:39 PM

        Not yet. If your following my blog, you get an email….

        Liked by 1 person

        S.Z. Estavillo responded:
        October 22, 2021 at 9:42 PM

        Yes, I’m following you. I’ll keep an eye out for it! 👏

        Liked by 1 person

    chrisr74 said:
    October 22, 2021 at 7:36 PM

    I’m definitely a pantser. Never been a fan of outlines as the story starts formulating in my head, and then it comes out of my fingers onto the screen. But then again I’m short form and have struck out trying to write a manuscript. I get distracted and bored or carried away on tangents. So perhaps for longer form outlining is the way to go! Great post as it got me thinking.

    Liked by 1 person

    macabeliam said:
    October 22, 2021 at 7:37 PM

    I heard Stephen King doesn’t plot, but J.K. Rowling does to a degree? They’re both great writers.

    Liked by 1 person

    Jack Eason said:
    October 22, 2021 at 9:41 PM

    Reblogged this on Have We Had Help? and commented:
    More from the lovely SZ 😉

    Liked by 1 person

    Stuart Danker said:
    November 1, 2021 at 8:17 PM

    I started out as a pantser, realised I’ve been writing myself into corners, tried my hand at plotting, but am reverting back to pantsing. I guess the most important bit about writing is figuring out what works for us specifically, lol. Sometimes even famous authors’ advice don’t blend well with our workflow. Anyway, thanks for this post!

    Liked by 1 person

      S.Z. Estavillo responded:
      November 1, 2021 at 8:20 PM

      I’m somewhere in between. I wrote out very light beats/scenes I need to hit and that seemed to help in terms of a direction.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.